SEPHORA Waterproof Smoky Cream Liner $10
A long-wearing, water-resistant, versatile eyeliner
This buttery, smooth-gliding liner in a jar is perfect for creating a variety of effects, from a fine line to lid-covering color. Whether your go thick, thin, smudged, or smoky, your look will last, from day to night
Umm I'm very curios about this one but i have a bad experience on Cream liner that is not M.A.C :S
So i don't know about this one